The Limits of Contractual Freedom in The Platform Economy: Toward Differentiated Protection for MSMEs and Digital Workers Under Indonesian Law

Platform Economy Freedom of Contract MSMEs Digital Workers Regulated Contractual Fairness

Authors

November 18, 2026

Downloads

The rapid expansion of digital platforms in Indonesia has reshaped commercial and employment relationships between platform operators and two distinct groups of participants: micro, small, and medium-sized enterprises (MSMEs) that rely on digital platforms for market access and digital platform workers who depend on these platforms for work opportunities and income. Although these groups occupy different legal positions under Indonesian law, both may be subject to structurally similar mechanisms of platform governance, including algorithmic ranking, account deactivation, automated performance evaluation, and unilateral modifications of contractual terms, which traditional principles of freedom of contract may not adequately address. This paper argues that Indonesian law governs these relationships through fragmented regulatory frameworks encompassing commercial law, consumer protection law, and labor law, none of which was specifically designed to address platform-related structural dependency. Consequently, contractual fairness must extend beyond contract formation to encompass the governance of ongoing contractual relationships. Drawing on a functional comparative analysis of the European Union's Platform-to-Business Regulation, Digital Services Act, and Platform Work Directive, this paper develops a differentiated framework of regulated contractual fairness. This framework establishes common procedural principles while proposing group-specific legal mechanisms that recognize the distinct legal status of MSMEs and digital platform workers. It emphasizes transparency, procedural accountability, safeguards against arbitrary platform decisions, and accessible dispute resolution mechanisms to address structural dependency and power imbalances within platform-mediated relationships.